Skip to main content

September 17, 1862, The "Clear Darkness" of Antietam, The Bloodiest Day In American History

 The bloodiest day in American History was the Battle of Antietam, near a small town in Maryland, Sharpsburg.


It was a horrific, stinking battle, highlighted by lunacy and incompetence on the Union side. It was like one of those World War I battles, in which all the fine young men , the best and the brightest, were force fed into the meat grinder of war, coming out on the other side, carnage.

It was a battle in which the Gods intervened, allowing the Union a chance to not only win the battle  but the war. A chance muffed by the hesitation of the Union Commander, George B. McClellan.

It was a battle in which Lee, greatly disadvantaged by this intervention of the Gods, showed his brilliance, and merit.

It was the Battle which triggered the Emancipation Proclamation.

At the beginning of the Battle, the Union Army, one of the finest armies in history, the Army of The Potomac, under McClellan had 80,000 troops; the Confederate Army, one of the finest armies in history, the Army of Northern Virginia, under Lee, diminished by straggling and desertion, had 50,000 men, maybe less.

130,000 met on the Battlefield; before nightfall 23,000 were either dead or wounded-THE BLOODIEST DAY IN AMERICAN HISTORY.

McClellan was one of the great organizing generals in American history, like George C. Marshall and Winfield Scott, but he was not a fighter like Eisenhower or Lee. He created great and beautiful armies to parade, not to fight.  War to him was the training camp; war to Lee was killing.

This Blogger believes that General Marshall, in World War II, deferred to Eisenhower as Field Commander because he saw his own fatal flaw; he was a McClellan, and Eisenhower was a fighter, who would give the order to land 250,000 warriors on  beaches, under withering fire.

Maryland was a slave holding state that had not left the Union; Lee had invaded Maryland to win them over to the Confederacy, and once that was done, gain the support for the Confederacy of the other  slave holding states that had not seceded(Kentucky, Missouri, Delaware),  effectively ending the war with a defacto  Southern victory.

The Army of the Potomac left Washington to chase down the Army of Northern Virginia.

At this particular juncture in human history, with Kutuzov and Wellington dead, with Winfield Scott to fat to mount a horse, Lee stood alone as the finest Field Commander (Strategy and Tactics)in the world, and would stay that way until Sherman assumed command of the Army of the Ohio.

Lee had just polished off the Army of the Potomac in the grueling Seven Days  and with a brilliant victory at the Second Battle of Bull Run.

Marching to catch the Rebs, the Union Army camped at a site just vacated by Confederate troops; there, to their astonishment, their stunned shock, was a bunch of cigars, wrapped in a piece of paper. The paper was confidential orders outlining  Lee's DETAILED BATTLE PLAN.

 "."The front side of Confederate Army Gen. Robert E. Lee's Special Order No. 191 dated Sept. 9, 1862. The handwritten document detailed the Southern commander's audacious plans for an invasion of enemy territory that would propel the Confederates to victory. Carelessly left behind as Lee's army marched north, the copy was spotted in a field by Union infantrymen and relayed up the North's chain of command."


Not since the Gods had intervened for  the Greeks over the Trojans had such a gift been given to a General as had been given to McClellan.

McClellan moved.

Dumbly, in full parade.

THE CORN FIELD

"Confederate troops began to see lines of Union soldiers advancing toward them as if on parade. The Confederates were positioned among rows of corn. Men on both sides opened fire, and for the next three hours the armies battled back and forth across the cornfield.

Thousands of men fired volleys of rifles and batteries of artillery from both sides raked the cornfield with grapeshot. Men fell, wounded or dead, in great numbers, but the fighting continued. The epic struggle in the cornfield became legendary, known as the bloodiest part of America's bloodiest day.

Fighting Joe Hooker, who would later command the Army of the Potomac, and  who would consider, after presumptively defeating Lee, overthrowing the Republic and installing a Caesar regime with himself as Caesar(Lincoln told him fine, just beat Lee first and then we will all take out chances). Fighting Joe Hooker, who was not shy about making  bloody war said this: "Every stalk of corn in the northern and greater part of the field was cut as closely as could have been done with a knife, and the slain lay in rows precisely as they had stood in their ranks a few moments before.

"It was never my fortune to witness a more bloody, dismal battle-field."


THE BLOODY LANE

Both Armies in the CORN FIELD  were exhausted by the CORN FIELD, so the fighting shifted to THE BLOODY LANE.

"The Confederates had found a natural defensive position, a narrow road used by farm wagons which had become sunken due to wear from wagon wheels and erosion caused by rain. This obscure sunken road would become famous as "Bloody Lane" by the end of the day.

Approaching five brigades of Confederates positioned in this natural trench, Union troops marched into a withering fire. Observers said the troops advanced across open fields "as if on parade." The shooting from the sunken road stopped the advance, but more Union troops came up behind those who had fallen."

Confederate sharp shooting stopped the Union advance in its tracks; to ask Union troops to continue to advance into THE BLOODY LANE  was like asking men to march into Hell; so naturally the Union commanders asked the Irish Brigade to do it, regiments of unwanted, unwashed, and illegal Irish immigrants were asked to do the impossible. 

"... Advancing under a green flag with a golden harp on it, the Irish fought their way to the sunken road and unleashed a furious volley of fire at the Confederate defenders.

The sunken road, now filled with Confederate corpses, was finally overtaken by Union troops. One soldier, shocked at the carnage, said the bodies in the sunken road were so thick that a man could have walked on them as far as he could see without touching the ground."

Both armies were exhausted by the fighting in THE CORN FIELD and THE BLOODY LANE, so the fighting shifted to the southern end of the battlefield, Burnside's Bridge.

Ambrose Burnside(who was later to command the Army of the Potomac) was the WORST general In American history, worse than Wilkinson,  Gates or Mark Clark-THE VERY WORST.

He was in command of Union troops.

He ordered his troops to charge a narrow stone bridge crossing the Antietam Creek.

Burnside funneled his troops onto a narrow bridge, "On the western side of the creek, a brigade of Confederate soldiers from Georgia positioned themselves on bluffs overlooking the bridge. From this perfect defensive position the Georgians were able to hold off the Union assault on the bridge for hours."

It was a turkey shoot for the Rebs.

Finally, in the late afternoon, boys from Brooklyn, and Pennsylvania just took the damn bridge in a heroic charge.

BURNSIDE THE WAR CRIMINAL, For Incompetence

"The attack at the bridge was actually unnecessary, as nearby fords would have allowed Burnside's troops to simply wade across the Antietam Creek."

Armies on the March have something called SCOUTS, among their job duties is to find fords across bodies of waters like creeks, streams, rivers.  Burnside did not even send out ONE DAMN SCOUT....but he did give us sideburns.

Confederate skill, and Union stupidity  had defeated God's gift to McClellan.

McClellan, could have finished the war right then, or lost the war entirely right then.

At Antietam, Porter commanded the Union Corps in Reserve; at that critical juncture of the war, McClellan became Pompey again to Lee's Caesar. He wavered, should he throw ALL his troops in? And risk losing everything including the war, if Lee counter punched.

McClellan sought advice from Porter, one Democrat to another.

Porter replied"Remember, General, I command the last reserve of the last Army of the Republic."

McClellan, the cautious Pompey did not throw all his troops into battle, leaving the battle a stalemate. The Army of the Potomac did not win the war that day, but also it was not destroyed that day by a Lee counter punch, which Stonewall Jackson would have delivered.

More blood, to pay for the blood of slaves harvested by the lash, would have to be expended to end the American calamity. Both armies were too exhausted and stunned by the killing spree to continue.

Lee withdrew to Virginia; Lincoln urged McClellan to pursue, but McClellan was paralyzed by so much blood being shed on his watch.

Lincoln fired him. McClellan ran as a Democrat against Lincoln in 1864, and LOST.

THE CLEAR DARKNESS

"CLEAR DARKNESS, when things get so dark, so black, so bleak you can suddenly see clearly. You are not blind in the darkness, you can see clearly because there are no distractions, no bothersome lights of distractions'.



Every year the Antietam illuminates the battlefield



THE CLEAR DARKNESS OF ANTIETAM and Great Britain


Up to Antietam, Great Britain had considered entering the war on the side of the Confederacy. But the immense casualties at Antietam, rivaling Waterloo, convinced the British that Lincoln was prepared to spend every drop of Union blood flowing to save the Union;  it dawned on the British that it would not be a good idea to join a fray against a man who could  preside over the bloodiest day in American history and still keep going forward toward  his goal.  As a result of Antietam, the British buried their plans to intervene in the American Civil War.

THE CLEAR DARKNESS OF ANTIETAM and THE EMANCIPATION PROCLAMATION

THE EMANCIPATION PROCLAMATION

During the Viet Nam War, the Republican Senator from Vermont, George Aitken, advised the Texan Lyndon Johnson to just declare  victory in a war America could not win and come home, another prime example of "Clear Darkness".

Antietam was not a Union victory; it was a stalemate, a draw.

But as Lincoln pondered the bloodiest day in American History, 23,000 dead or wounded IN ONE DAY; he had his moment of Clear Darkness. He came to understand that the American Civil War, to justify all the dead and all the dead coming, needed  a moral component.

Therefore, this Man who in March  1861, had offered the South a Constitutional Amendment guaranteeing eternal and perpetual Slavery, decided to issue the Emancipation Proclamation.

".Lincoln issued a preliminary decree stating that, unless the rebellious states returned to the Union by January 1, freedom would be granted to slaves within those states. The decree also left room for a plan of compensated emancipation. No Confederate states took the offer, and on January 1 Lincoln presented the Emancipation Proclamation. The proclamation declared, "all persons held as slaves within any States, or designated part of the State, the people whereof shall be in rebellion against the United States, shall be then, thenceforward, and forever free."

The Emancipation Proclamation did not free all slaves in the United States. Rather, it declared free only those slaves living in states not under Union control.


William Seward, Lincoln's secretary of state, commented, "We show our sympathy with slavery by emancipating slaves where we cannot reach them and holding them in bondage where we can set them free." 

 Lincoln was fully aware of the irony, but he did not want to antagonize the slave states loyal to the Union by setting their slaves free. (Missouri,Kentucky,Delaware and Maryland).

Regardless of the ironic shortcomings of the Proclamation, it did mean, that in the Clear Darkness of Antietam, the boys had died for something of value - freedom in a new place.



Burnside's bridge


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Urination Of Nicole Kidman's Career

I went to see EYES WIDE SHUT in total awe of its Director, Stanley Kubrick, who had in his career Directed THE GREATEST Science Fiction/Cosmological film EVER- 2001, SPACE ODYSSEY, the BEST and MOST INSIGHTFUL film essay on American culture EVER- LOLITA, arguably the greatest war movie ever- PATHS OF GLORY, and one of the best film epics ever- SPARTACUS. Mr. Kubrick died SUDDENLY, before EYES WIDE SHUT was released. Everyone was so sad. Then I saw EYES WIDE SHUT, and understood exactly why Herr Director Kubrick had croaked so suddenly; he had willed himself to death before the release of the film, so that  he would not have to suffer the slings and shots against his declining genius. EYES WIDE SHUT is the WORST, laughably worst, porn film ever made, EVER. It starred that larger than life couple(at the time), Tom Cruise and Nicole Kidman. The key scene in the film was Ms. Kidman peeing. I was spending over $60.00(including tickets,parking and snacks for me and my date ) to watch

The Crash of Flight 447: Fate, Moliere and Veronique Gaignard

In 1954 there was the film, THE HIGH AND THE MIGHTY about danger in the air; that was followed by the 1964 film, FATE IS THE HUNTER about a fatal airplane crash and the followup investigation; followed by the 1970 film, AIRPORT, about a bomber on a plane, starring every living star in Hollywood at the time; followed by  the sequels, AIRPORT 75, AIRPORT 77, AIRPORT 79- THE CONCORDE. All that melodramatic danger in the air was laughed to death by the films AIRPLANE in 1980, followed by AIRPLANE II in 1982. Everything in air flight had been covered, both the tragedy and the comedy  of air travel, until Air France Flight 447. Flight 447 was the Air France  Airbus Flight from Brazil to France, which,in 2009, crashed in the South Atlantic , killing all on board,228 passengers. Airbuses fly by wire, which means they fly by computers rather than the old mechanical ways.  Very up to date, except when something goes awry, then it seems it is very difficult to set right. In the wee hours

Roger Cohen's Russian Think Piece in NEW YORK TIMES Begs the Question: Was Gerry Maxey Right about Russia TEN YEARS AGO?

  This Blogger respects Russians; as Frederick the Great stated :” It takes two bullets to take a Russian soldier out; one to kill him and one to  stop him.” This Blogger   likes Russians; even though once, in Moscow, during the Soviet era, his incredibly attractive tour guide, aka KGB agent, told him and his brother   that they were in danger of being hit, fatally, by a Soviet car crossing a Moscow street. T his Blogger’s brother told her that he had ridden in a Soviet Car, the LADA; and that he could damn well survive any hit by that piece of junk. She laughed. That night, this Blogger’s brother slept in his room, under his bed, drunk. This Blogger admires the way Russians do business; when Soviet diplomats were kidnapped in Lebanon, the KGB paid the ransoms immediately, without complaint. Shortly thereafter, Beirut was flooded with Soviet agents and Soviet bribes; the kidnappers were identified. They were abducted, tortured and  castrated; their dead bodies strung from l